From paper stamp card to wallet pass in one afternoon
Why paper cards get lost, and how to switch your regulars to a digital card without losing a single stamp.

Paper stamp cards work, until they end up in the wash. Most cafés we talk to estimate that more than half of their cards never come back full. That is not because customers don't like the reward. They just don't have the card with them.
Why the wallet works better
A wallet pass lives on the phone, next to boarding passes and concert tickets. It is there at every visit, it shows progress on the lock screen, and it can't be copied with a home-made stamp.
Switching without losing stamps
Keep accepting paper cards for a few weeks. When a customer hands one in, scan their new pass and add the stamps they already had. Put a QR code on the counter and on every receipt, and train staff to ask one question: "Do you want your stamps on your phone?"
What to measure
Track how many passes are added per week and how many come back for a second visit. Those two numbers tell you whether the program is working long before the first card is full.